hammer 74
3:35 Mon Sep 22
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
Carroll is good at bringing the ball down, shielding it and bringing others into play, not just his heading and presence in the box. Plus it's always good to be able to have different players and different approaches to games. I see no reason why Carroll couldn't play with the likes of Sakho/Valencia/Downing either side of him or supporting him.
|
Dicksy for England
3:31 Mon Sep 22
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
Carroll in a side playing with style but also getting telling crosses in (unlike the lumped up crap we saw last season) could be dynamite.
|
twoleftfeet
1:16 Mon Sep 22
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
Any complaints?
YES! Lets not ditch BFS just yet,Im quite enjoying the ride at the moment.
|
DaillyShaggedMyWife
1:14 Mon Sep 22
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
Carroll is a much footballer than people give him credit for, and could work well in a footballing side imo.
However, because of his height/ability in the air, physicality and reputation, he seems to be an excuse for manager and players alike (Collins mainly) to go long all the time.
Also, this is his third big injury with us in three seasons including his loan spell. If we can get close to the money we paid for him I'd take it and move on.
|
Wham1966
1:14 Mon Sep 22
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
JayeMPee 1:09 Mon Sep 22
Newcastle relegation = Pardew sacked.
Sam IN Carroll IN Nolan IN at St Jamessss Park.
Any complaints?
|
twoleftfeet
1:11 Mon Sep 22
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
Ill happily drive him for free up to the North East for his medical.
Which he will fail.
|
JayeMPee
1:09 Mon Sep 22
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
Good, keep him fit and let him go for a reasonable price he is too injury prone. And he can take Nolan with him.
|
Razzle
10:37 Mon Sep 22
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
A fit Andy Carroll would be such a menace against Man U next week....But you need to get more games out of him in a season....and for that reason i'm out.
|
Leigh Jim
10:37 Mon Sep 22
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
A front three of him Valencia and sakho
Song kouyate and noble behind
- with downing, zarate and Morrison, Jarvis, poyet and amalfatini to slot in where need be
Just can't see where Nolan fits into that though
|
greek hammer
10:29 Mon Sep 22
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
hoofball.....(equals goofball)
|
greek hammer
10:29 Mon Sep 22
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
let him go...not only is he injury prone,he is BFS's best excuse for goofball....I would throw in Nolan as well....
|
teacoffeeteacoffee
8:44 Mon Sep 22
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
Norflundon 8:19 Mon Sep 22
Completely disagree, I reckon he'd go back in a hearbeat. Opinions though innit, like arseholes, we've all got one.
|
crapnotshit
8:34 Mon Sep 22
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
He's got immense physics, limited skills and gets very easily injuries.
With his sell off value and cages, we could buy two decent strikers as cover to the ones we have got.
That means, if toons want him we should add Cole and Nolan in that deal just to get rid!
|
Norflundon
8:19 Mon Sep 22
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
Don't think he'd go back up there
|
Chip Shop Charlie
7:54 Mon Sep 22
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
If he was a horse he'd be in Ikea meetballs by now.
|
Mr Polite
7:48 Mon Sep 22
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
He is not anywhere near the great player some suggest and when he is in the team he makes us play in a way that doesn't suit us. Add to that his fitness and attitude to it then I'd say he is nowhere near worth the wages he is stealing from us.
|
Balto
6:22 Mon Sep 22
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
Bite their magpie hands off. Take KN with you too.
|
franksfat&slow&wank
9:10 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
Teams pay silly money when staring at relegation ... I wouldn't rule the Geordies coming in for him tbh
|
Reality Cheques
9:09 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
He's a decent player when fit & is off the sauce & focused.
Trouble is that isn't very often.
If we get a decent offer & by that I'd say between £10 - £12 mil I think we should take it & run.
How likely that would be is doubtful, but anything less & or pay & play offers then I'd hold on to him & hope for the best.
|
backpass
8:42 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
keep a big squad with various options and dispel the Westwham way rumour once and for all.
|
Arko
8:41 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
Hopefully the medics in the USA got it right this time.
If they tell us Carroll should be injury free he could be a very good option for us, if there is the slightest doubt he'll go down again we should try to sell him...
|
| 
